🎨 How to Fix Common Acrylic Painting Mistakes (And Why They’re Actually Good for You!)
If you’ve ever stared at your canvas thinking “I’ve completely ruined it,” you’re not alone. Every single painter—beginner or professional—has been there. The good news? Acrylic paint is one of the most forgiving mediums out there, and most “mistakes” are actually opportunities to learn and create something even better.
Let’s walk through the most common acrylic painting mishaps and, more importantly, how to fix them. Your painting isn’t ruined—it’s just asking for a little problem-solving!
Muddy Colors: When Your Painting Loses Its Brightness
What happened: You mixed your colors and instead of that vibrant purple you wanted, you got…brown. Or you painted one color over another and everything turned into a dull, muddy mess.
Why it happens: Muddy colors usually come from mixing complementary colors (colors opposite each other on the color wheel, like red and green, or blue and orange). While this is great for creating neutrals, it can accidentally dull your painting when you don’t want it to.
The fix:
Let it dry completely, then paint over the muddy area with a fresh, vibrant color. Acrylics are opaque enough to cover previous layers beautifully.
- Embrace it! Sometimes muddy colors make fantastic shadows or backgrounds. If it’s in an area that could use some depth, consider working with it rather than against it.
- Add white or a lighter tint of your intended color on top to brighten the area back up.
- Going forward: Clean your brush thoroughly between colors, and try mixing colors on your palette first to see what you’ll get.
Paint Applied Too Thick: The Lumpy, Bumpy Surface
What happened: You got excited and squeezed paint straight from the tube onto your canvas, or you layered on paint with a heavy hand. Now you have texture where you didn’t want it.
Why it happens: Enthusiasm! It’s actually a common beginner move because acrylic paint is so satisfying to apply.
The fix:
-If it’s still wet: Use a palette knife to gently scrape off the excess paint. You can wipe the knife clean and keep going until you reach your desired thickness.
- If it’s dry: You have options! You can sand it down gently with fine-grit sandpaper once completely dry (give it 24 hours), or paint over it with thinner layers. If the texture bothers you in one spot but not others, you can add more texture elsewhere to make it look intentional.
- Creative solution: Sometimes happy accidents are the best! That thick paint could become an interesting focal point or add dimension you didn’t know you needed.
Paint Applied Too Thin: Streaky, See-Through Layers
What happened: Your paint looks watery and streaky, and you can see the canvas or previous layers showing through when you don’t want them to.
Why it happens: Either you added too much water to your paint, or you didn’t apply enough paint to get good coverage.
The fix:
- Add another coat! This is the easiest fix. Let your first layer dry completely (acrylics dry fast—usually 15-30 minutes for thin layers), then apply a second or even third coat for solid coverage.
- Use less water: If you’re thinning your paint, remember that a little water goes a long way. Your paint should be more like cream than milk.
- Try better coverage: Load your brush with more paint and use confident strokes rather than scrubbing the paint on.
- For intentional transparency: If you actually want a watercolor effect, thin layers are perfect! Just make sure it’s a choice, not an accident.
Wonky Proportions: When Things Don’t Look Quite Right
What happened: Your tree is way too big for your house, or one eye is noticeably higher than the other, or that apple looks more like a potato.
Why it happens: Our eyes can trick us, especially when we’re focused on one area at a time. We lose sight of how everything relates to each other.
The fix:
- Step back regularly: This is the #1 tip. Put your painting across the room and look at it from a distance. Proportions issues become obvious when you’re not up close.
- Paint over and adjust: Once the area is dry, simply paint over it with your background color and redo it. You might need 2-3 layers to cover completely, but acrylics are great for this.
- Use a reference photo: Take a picture of your painting with your phone. Sometimes seeing it in a different format helps you spot proportion issues.
- Measure as you go: For the next painting, use a pencil or brush handle to compare sizes before you commit to paint. Hold it at arm’s length and use your thumb to mark measurements.
-Next time: sketch out the proportions with a pencil before you paint.
Accidental Drips and Smudges: The “How Did That Get There?” Mystery
What happened: You’ve got a paint drip running down your canvas, or you accidentally smudged a wet area with your hand or sleeve.
Why it happens: Acrylic paint is wet and you’re human! This happens to everyone, especially when you’re in the creative zone and not paying attention to your surroundings.
The fix:
- Catch it wet: If you spot the drip or smudge immediately, gently wipe it away with a damp paper towel or baby wipe.
- If it’s partially dry: Let it dry completely, then paint over it. Don’t try to wipe partially-dry acrylic—you’ll just spread it around and make it worse.
- For stubborn spots: Once dry, you can carefully scrape off raised drips with a craft knife or razor blade, then touch up the area with paint.
- Prevention: Work on a flat surface when possible, use a mahl stick (or ruler) to rest your hand on when painting details, and keep paper towels handy for quick cleanups.
Overworked Paint: When You Just Can’t Stop Fiddling
What happened: You kept going back to adjust, blend, and “fix” an area, and now it looks worse than when you started. The paint might be disturbing the layer beneath it, or colors are getting muddy.
Why it happens: Perfectionism and impatience! We want it to look “just right,” but acrylic paint starts to get tacky as it dries, which makes it harder to blend smoothly.
The fix:
- Stop and walk away! Seriously. Let it dry completely. Acrylic dries fast, so come back in 30 minutes to an hour.
- Paint fresh layers: Once dry, you can paint right over the overworked area with fresh paint. It’s like starting with a clean slate.
- Use a glazing medium: For your next painting, try adding a glazing medium to your paint. This extends the drying time and makes blending much easier.
- Work faster or in sections: Either embrace working quickly while the paint is wet, or work on one section at a time and let it dry before moving to the adjacent area.
- Remember: Sometimes “good enough” is actually great! Step back and you might realize it looks better than you thought.
The Most Important Fix of All: Your Mindset
Here’s the secret that experienced painters know: mistakes aren’t failures—they’re how you learn. Every “ruined” painting teaches you something valuable. Maybe you learn that you need less water in your mix, or that you should let layers dry longer, or that you actually love the texture you created by accident.
Some of the most beautiful paintings have happy accidents built into them. That unexpected color? It might be the perfect shadow. That drip you couldn’t remove? It could add movement and energy to your piece.
Be patient with yourself. Acrylic painting is a skill, and skills take practice. Every single painting you create—whether you love it or want to hide it in a closet—is making you a better artist.
-----
Ready to Build Your Skills with Confidence?
Learning to paint doesn’t have to be overwhelming or expensive. Our Beginner Paint Subscription is designed specifically for artists who are just starting out and want to grow their skills one painting at a time.
For just $8.88 a month**, you’ll get:
- Step-by-step painting tutorials
- Beginner-friendly techniques explained clearly
- Tips and tricks for avoiding common mistakes
- Fresh paintings every month
No expensive supplies to buy. No confusing art jargon. Just clear, encouraging guidance to help you create paintings you’re proud of.
Join today and start painting with confidence!
Remember: Every artist started exactly where you are now. The only difference between a beginner and an experienced painter is practice—and we’re here to help you every step of the way.